Measuring Integration of Disabled Persons: Evidence from Canada’s Time Use Databases

Clarke Wilson, Mary Ann McColl, Fang Zhang, Paige McKinnon

Abstract


Disability is defined in terms of activity limitation. We propose using daily time use data as a macro indicator of the degree of integration of people with disabilities into the wider society. If activity patterns of disabled persons are becoming more similar to those of the general population, this indicates a reduction in activity limitation and suggests opportunity and social integration are increasing. Decreasing similarity of activity patterns would indicate a failure of policies promoting integration. Data on daily activities were drawn from Statistics Canada General Social Survey files for the cycles focusing on time use for 1992 and 2010. Canada-wide there has been a convergence of the activities of disabled and non-disabled persons of about 13 percent over the period examined. Convergence has been slightly greater for disabled women than men. The major source of convergence for disabled women has been a very large increase in paid work time as compared with disabled men. Our results are consistent with the proposition that public policy on disability is succeeding, but the attribution of activity convergence to policy and program interventions would require a great deal of additional research. 


Keywords


Integration; Daily activity; Time use; Policy evaluation; Program effectiveness

Full Text:

HTML PDF

References


Brandon, P. 2007. “Time Away from Smelling the Roses: Where do Mothers Raising Children

with Disabilities Find the Time to Work?” Social Science Medicine 65 (4): 667-79.

Chio, A., A. Gauthier, A. Vignola, A. Calvo, P. Ghiglione, E. Cavallo, A.A. Terreni, and R.

Mutani. 2006. “Caregiver Time Use in ALS.” Neurology 67 (5): 902-4.

Crowe, T. K., and S. I. Florez. 2006. “Time Use of Mothers with School-Age Children: A

Continuing Impact of a Child’s Disability.” American Journal of Occupational Therapy 60 (2): 194-203.

Eklund, M., C. Leufstadius, and U. Bejerholm. 2009. “Time Use Among People with Psychiatric

Disabilities: Implications for Practice.” Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal 32 (3): 177-91.

Employment and Skills Development Canada. 2010. Federal Disability Report. Ottawa.

Employment and Skills Development Canada. 2011. Federal Disability Report: Seniors with

Disabilities in Canada. Ottawa.

Grondin, C. 2016. A New Survey Measure of Disability: the Disability Screening Questions

(DSQ). Statistics Canada catalogue 89-654-x2016003.

Harvey, A. 1982. Studies in Broadcasting 18, Role and Context: Shapers of Behaviour. Nippon

Hoso Kyokai, Tokyo.

Human Resources and Skills Development Canada. 2012. Federal Disability Reference Guide.

Ottawa.

Joiner, I. 2006. “Obscuring Disability: The Impact of a Universalism/Minority Group Dichotomy

on Assessing Equality.” In Disability and Social Policy in Canada, edited by M. A. McColl and L. Jongbloed. Toronto: Captus.

Kitterod, R. H., and T. H. Lyngstad. (2004). “Diary Versus Questionnaire Information on Time

Spend on Housework – The Case of Norway.” International Journal of Time Use Research 2: 13-32.

Law, M. 2002. “Participation in the Occupations of Everyday Life.” American Journal of

Occupational Therapy 56 (6): 640-9.

Lomax, C. L., R. G. Brown, and R. J. Howard. 2004. “Measuring Disability in Patients with

Neurodegenerative Disease using the 'Yesterday Interview.'” International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 19 (11): 1058-64.

McColl, M. A., and R. Bond. 2013. “A Scoping Review of Disability Policy in Canada.”

http://www.disabilitypolicyalliance.ca/federal_policy_team/federal_disabilitypolicyscans/a-scoping-review-of-disability-policy-in-canada.html.

McColl, M. A., and L. Jongbloed. 2006. Disability & Social Policy in Canada (2nd ed.) Toronto:

Captus Press.

McColl, M. A., and R. Stevenson. 2008. A Scoping Review of Disability Policy in Canada:

Effects on Community Integration for People with Spinal Cord Injuries. Report to the Spinal Cord Injury Solutions Network, http://69.89.31.83/~disabio5/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/A-Scoping-Review-of-Disability-Policy-In-Canada.pdf

McColl, M. A., C. Wilson, P. MacKinnon, and F. Zhang. 2014. “How Does Disability Affect

Time Use?” poster presented at the International Association for Time Use Research, 36th annual conference, Turku Finland, July 30 – August 2.

Nierobisz, A. C., and C. Theroux. 2008. Disability Complaints Submitted to the Canadian

Human Rights Commission: An Analysis of Systemic Barriers Reported by Complainants. Canadian Human Right Commission Report.

Nordberg, G., A. Wimo, L. Jonsson, I. Kareholt, B. M. Sjolund, M. Lagergren, E. von Strauss.

“Time Use and Costs of Institutionalised Elderly Persons With or Without Dementia: Results from the Nordanstig Cohort in the Kungsholmen Project--A Population Based Study in Sweden.” International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 22 (7): 639-48.

Parliament of Canada. 1981. Obstacles: Report of the Special Committee on the Disabled and the

Handicapped. First session, thirty-second parliament, 1980-81 (Cat. No. XC 2-321/5-O3E).

Pentland, W., A. S. Harvey, T. Smith, and J. Walker. 1999a. “The Impact of Spinal Cord Injury

on Men’s Time Use.” Spinal Cord 37: 786-792.

Pentland, W, A. S. Harvey, M. P. Lawton, and M. A. McColl. eds. 1999b. Time Use Research in

the Social Sciences. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.

Statistics Canada. 2011. General Social Survey 2010 - Overview of Time Use of Canadians.

Catalogue 89-647.

Statistics Canada. 2013. Disability in Canada: Initial Findings from the Canadian Survey on

Disability. Catalogue 89-654x, #2.

Stewart, J. 2006. “Assessing Alternative Dissimilarity Indexes for Comparing Activity Profiles.”

International Journal of Time Use Research 3 (1): 48-59.

United Nations Organization (2007), Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.

http://www.un.org/disabilities/convention/conventionfull.shtml#top

Wilson, W. C. 1998. “Activity Pattern Analysis by Means of Sequence Alignment Methods.”

Environment and Planning 30: 1017-1038.

Wilson, C. 2008. “Activity Patterns in Space and Time: Calculating Representative Hagerstrand

Trajectories.” Transportation 35: 485-499.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15353/cjds.v6i1.335

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




 

The Canadian Journal of Disability Studies is Published by the Canadian Disability Studies Association-Association Canadienne des Études sur l'Incapacité, and is hosted and supported by the University of Waterloo.

ISSN 1929-9192 Canadian Journal of Disability Studies (Online)